Definitions, Examples,

IDevice Icon Evaluation vs. Description

Evaluative language causes defensiveness by passing judgment on the person and making them the focus of the problem. Evaluative language judges, quantifies or accuses ("you" language).

Descriptive communication focuses on the problem as separate from the other persons. Descriptive language focueses on the speaker's perceptions ("I" language).

Check the examples below as either Evaluative or Descriptive.


IDevice Question Icon Evaluative or Descriptive?
You are not making yourself clear to me.
       
Evaluative
Descriptive

I feel uncomfortable with the way this discussion is going.
       
Evaluative
Descriptive

IDevice Icon Control vs. Problem Orientation

Control messages impose one person's views on another withot concern or interest in what the other thinks or feels while problem orientation signals respect and the desire to make a decision or find an agreeable solution.

Controlling communication suggests the speaker has power over the hearer. Problem-oriented communication empowers the hearer by portraying a more collaborative relationship between the parties.

Check the examples below as either Controlling or Problem-oriented.


IDevice Question Icon Controlling or Problem-Oriented?
I would like to work with you to come up with the best solution.
       
Controlling
Problem-oriented

You need to call all your parents by 4:00 pm Friday.
       
Controlling
Problem-oriented

IDevice Icon Strategic vs. Spontaneous

Strategic Communication refers to a speaker with an agenda or ulterior motive while spontaneity, in the sense of honest and forthright communication, refers to a speaker who shares thoughts and feelings openly.

Strategic communication makes the hearer feel manipulated.  Spontaneous communication clarifies the speaker's needs and includes the hearer in the brainstorming solutions. 


IDevice Question Icon Strategic or Spontaneous?
If you don't have plans for this weekend we really need you to come to the office to help finish this project.
       
Strategic
Spontaneous

I'm feeling stressed about finishing this project on time, do you have any ideas?
       
Strategic
Spontaneous

IDevice Icon Neutral vs. Empathic

Neutral communication does NOT offer a diplomatic point of view on an issue--it conveys indifferent to the other, while empathy involves understanding a ppreciating the other's feelings.

Neutral communication is threatening to the hearer's self-worth.  Empathic communication confirms and validates the concerns of the hearer. 


IDevice Question Icon Neutral or Empathic?
I understand it is hard to make time, please do the best you can.
       
Neutral
Empathic

I don't care how you get it done, just get it done.
       
Neutral
Empathic

IDevice Icon Superior vs. Equal

Superior communication sends the message that all others are inferior or inadequate in some way; therefore, the speaker has no interest in what they might say.   Equal communication sends the message that the other is valued and worthy as a human being.  

Superior language emphasizes the unique skill or expertise of the speaker to cause the hearer to feel insignificant.  Communication based on equality empowers the hearer and values their contribution. 


IDevice Question Icon Superior or Equal?
Based on my 20 years of teaching you should listen to me.
       
Superior
Equal

Working together as a team is important to me.
       
Superior
Equal

IDevice Icon Certainty vs. Provisionalism

Speakers who communicate with certainty come across as narrow-minded and unwilling to listen to another point of view while provisional communication involves acknoledging other points of view and possibilities.

Language of certainty suggests there is only one answer, and the speaker has it.  Provisional language tells the hearer that speaker is open to suggestions. 


IDevice Question Icon Certainty or Provisionalism?
The only way to get through to parents is to let the child fail.
       
Certainty
Provisionalism

I have usually done it this way, but what ideas do you have?
       
Certainty
Provisionalism

Please continue to apply what you have learned about Defensive and Supportive Communication.

Licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 2.5 License

Brought to you by creducation.org